Question 1

Is Fair Deal Home Buyers legit?

Accepted Answer

Fair Deal Home Buyers is a cash home buyer serving the Milwaukee, WI area. Google reviews from the last 12 months average 4.6★, down from 5.0★ in the 12 months before (as of September 2026). By Google review count (115), Fair Deal Home Buyers is 2nd of the 48 buyers we list in the Milwaukee, WI area. The name on its BBB profile is Fair Deal Home Buyers LLC. Its CashBuyerRated score of 86/100 places it #6 among 21 scored buyers in the Milwaukee, WI area; confidence in the score is high. Google shows a 4.9-star average from 115 reviews (as of October 2026); the median for scored buyers in the Milwaukee, WI area is 5. Its Google reviews start in August 2020, about 4 years after its website, fairdealhomebuyers.com, was registered in October 2016. CashBuyerRated has not yet received verified seller reviews for Fair Deal Home Buyers.

Question 2

Has Fair Deal Home Buyers' Google rating changed over time?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Google reviews posted in the last 12 months average 4.6★, down from 5.0★ in the 12 months before, as of September 2026. By year: 2022 4.8★ (18 reviews), 2023 4.8★ (27 reviews), 2024 5.0★ (27 reviews), 2025 4.8★ (21 reviews), 2026 5.0★ (7 reviews). Google itself shows only the lifetime average (4.9★).

Question 3

Are there complaints about Fair Deal Home Buyers?

Accepted Answer

4 of Fair Deal Home Buyers' 115 Google reviews (3%) are 1 or 2 stars, as of October 2026. Of the 4 low-star reviews among its 115 most recent, the company publicly replied to 3. Its Better Business Bureau rating is A+ (checked September 2026); complaints filed with the BBB are listed on its BBB profile. Reading the 1 and 2 star reviews on Google shows what those reviewers reported.

Question 4

How does selling to Fair Deal Home Buyers work?

Accepted Answer

According to its website, Fair Deal Home Buyers says it buys houses as-is, with no repairs needed, its offers come with no obligation and it can close in as little as 3 days. As with any cash sale, the offer becomes a written purchase agreement and closing is handled by a title company or attorney. Before you sign, check who holds the deposit and ask whether Fair Deal Home Buyers will buy the house itself or assign the contract to another investor.

Question 5

What is Fair Deal Home Buyers' phone number?

Accepted Answer

The phone number on Fair Deal Home Buyers' Google listing is (414) 409-8251 (414-409-8251). Cash buyers often call or text from other numbers too. If a number that contacted you isn't listed, ask the caller for the company's full legal name before sharing details about your home.

Question 6

How fast can Fair Deal Home Buyers close?

Accepted Answer

Fair Deal Home Buyers says on its website that it can close in as little as 3 days. Closing speed depends on title work and your situation. Ask for the closing date in writing.

Question 7

What is Fair Deal Home Buyers' Google rating?

Accepted Answer

As of October 2026, Fair Deal Home Buyers has a 4.9-star average across 115 Google reviews.

Fair Deal Home Buyers reviews

Is Fair Deal Home Buyers legit?

Average of Google reviews by year

Verified seller reviews

Fact sheet

What Fair Deal Home Buyers says

Situations it says it handles

Common questions about Fair Deal Home Buyers