Cream City Home Buyers reviews
Cash home buyer · Milwaukee, WI · Website since 2017
Preliminary · medium confidence. How it works · How we score
Is Cream City Home Buyers legit?
Cream City Home Buyers is a cash home buyer in the Milwaukee, WI area. None of its 36 Google reviews are 1 star as of October 2026; the median share among scored buyers in the Milwaukee, WI area is 0%. It ranks #8 of 21 scored cash home buyers in the Milwaukee, WI area by CashBuyerRated score (82/100, medium confidence). According to its own site, it buys houses as-is, it pays closing costs and its offers are no-obligation. On Google, it has a 5-star average across 36 reviews as of October 2026. Cream City Home Buyers picked up 1 Google review in the past 12 months (0 in the last 90 days), against a median of 4 among scored buyers in the Milwaukee, WI area. Cream City Home Buyers publicly answered 97% of its recent Google reviews (36 sampled), compared with a 84% median in the Milwaukee, WI area. CashBuyerRated has not yet received verified seller reviews for Cream City Home Buyers.
Facts only, from public sources listed below. We don't make judgments about companies; this is a summary of public facts.
Average of Google reviews by year
Average of Google reviews posted each year. Google only shows the lifetime average.
Based on the 36 most recent Google reviews, back to September 2018. Shows up to the 5 most recent years with 3 or more reviews. Source: Google Maps, September 2026.
Verified seller reviews
0 reviewsNo verified reviews yet. Each review answers what matters with cash buyers: offer held at closing, closed on time, clear about who's buying and communication.
Sold your house to Cream City Home Buyers? Tell other homeowners what really happened.
Write a reviewVerified sellers only. Reviews can't be bought, hidden, or deleted by the company.
Fact sheet
- Google rating
- 5★ from 36 reviews
- Google Maps, October 2026
- Most recent Google review
- Nov 3, 2025 (11 months ago)
- Google Maps, September 2026
- New Google reviews
- 0 in the last 90 days · 1 in the last 12 months
- Google Maps, September 2026
- Replies to Google reviews
- 97% of the 36 most recent reviews
- Google Maps, September 2026
- Website first registered
- November 2017 (8 yrs)
- Public domain registry
- Google listing
- Claimed by the business
- Google Maps, October 2026
- Locations on Google
- 1
- Google Maps, October 2026
- Phone
- (414) 488-0082
- Google Maps
- Website
- creamcityhomebuyers.com
- Google Maps; checked September 2026
What Cream City Home Buyers says
From creamcityhomebuyers.com, checked September 2026. These are the company's own claims, not verified by CashBuyerRated.
- Says it pays closing costs
- Says it buys houses as-is, no repairs
- Says offers are no-obligation
Situations it says it handles
Common questions about Cream City Home Buyers
Does Cream City Home Buyers reply to its Google reviews?
Cream City Home Buyers has replied to 97% of its 36 most recent Google reviews, as of September 2026. The median reply rate among scored buyers in the Milwaukee, WI area is 84%.
Are there complaints about Cream City Home Buyers?
None of Cream City Home Buyers' 36 Google reviews are 1 or 2 stars (as of October 2026).
How does selling to Cream City Home Buyers work?
According to its website, Cream City Home Buyers says it buys houses as-is, with no repairs needed, its offers come with no obligation and it pays closing costs. As with any cash sale, the offer becomes a written purchase agreement and closing is handled by a title company or attorney. Before you sign, check who holds the deposit and ask whether Cream City Home Buyers will buy the house itself or assign the contract to another investor.
What is Cream City Home Buyers' phone number?
The phone number on Cream City Home Buyers' Google listing is (414) 488-0082 (414-488-0082). Cash buyers often call or text from other numbers too. If a number that contacted you isn't listed, ask the caller for the company's full legal name before sharing details about your home.
What is Cream City Home Buyers' Google rating?
As of October 2026, Cream City Home Buyers has a 5-star average across 36 Google reviews.
Compare other Milwaukee cash home buyers
See all 48Two leading scored options, then nearby listed locations where coordinates are available. Distances are straight-line between business listings, not from your home or a confirmed service area. Wider-metro options and unavailable distances are labeled. See the city list for every profile and the full ranking.
414 HomebuyersLeading metro score · about 8 mi between listingsScore 90 · 4.9★ · 151 Google reviews
Sell Now WisconsinLeading metro score · Brookfield · about 6 mi between listingsScore 90 · 5★ · 41 Google reviews- Laurel Buys HousesNearby listed location · Greenfield · about 3 mi between listingsScore 80 · 5★ · 25 Google reviews
Cash House Buyer Greenfield WINearby listed location · Greenfield · about 5 mi between listingsScore 82 · 5★ · 12 Google reviews
Milwaukee Plan B HomeBuyersNearby listed location · Brookfield · about 6 mi between listingsScore 84 · 4.7★ · 43 Google reviews
Simply Sold RENearby listed location · Franklin · about 7 mi between listingsScore 75 · 5★ · 17 Google reviews
Last updated October 2026. Information comes from public sources and the company's own website and may change. Verify details directly with Cream City Home Buyers before you sign anything.
Request a correction